RSS
 

Our obsession with breasts: breast cancer month

11 Oct

Breast cancer is not the number one killer in America. It is not the number one killer of women.

All cancers, as a category, are the #3 killer, below heart disease, which is #2. But breast cancer kills less people than stroke (cardiovascular disease), chronic lower respiratory diseases, accidents (unintentional injuries), Alzheimer’s disease, diabetes, nephritis-nephrotic syndrome-and-nephrosis, and even the flu, according to the CDC.

Despite all of these other causes of death killing more of our loved ones than breast cancer, it’s the disease that gets the most attention. The capital building here in Denver has a big pink ribbon on it, as do cars on the street, and food packaging in every grocery store.

I’m not questioning people’s desire to have a cure for diseases. I’m questioning why one disease trumps so many others which together are 50 times as fatal.

It seems that this is our proud-as-a-peacock display of the objectification of women. We care more about breast cancer, even though it’s only the cause of 2% of deaths in America, because it’s about breasts. Promotional material has gotten more honest, at least, like the “boobies” bumper sticker I took a photo of recently. [Post continues below.]

"Boobies" bumper sticker

It’s understandable that we use our bodies as part of our self worth, and that’s another reason it’s significant. We value our bodies to the level of idolatry, and judge our self-worth as men and women by things that set us apart from each other, particularly in sexual ways. This self-view is something Christians are supposed to fight against as it is contrary to what the Bible teaches. Jesus taught that one’s life is more important than any individual body part (Matthew 5:29-30,6:25), and Paul taught that the marks of true femininity was not in appearance, but in character and good deeds (1 Timothy 2:8-10). (The same is true of men, who are supposed to stand out spiritually and in prayer, lifting holy hands in praying for their authorities without anger or disputing.)

Obviously men like breasts for primal, cultural, and primarily sexual reasons as well. Perhaps that really is what it all comes down to for many people – we support breast cancer research more than anything else because heart disease and Alzheimer’s disease doesn’t make us think of sex.

I hope we have a cure for breast cancer soon. I also hope we have a cure for Alzheimer’s disease, heart disease, diabetes, and other killers. I am troubled that a disease that ranks so low on the list has taken over because the over-sexualization  of our culture.

Please leave comments if there’s reasons I’m unaware of that this 2% killer trumps all others. I’d be interested to learn the answer to this riddle.

Oh – and what is the number one killer in America? Abortion is the number one killer in America. For every 1 woman that dies from breast cancer, 20 babies are aborted – and this only includes legal abortions that are are reported. Twenty.

 
 

Tags: , , , , , ,

  • Mia

    in 2010 the American Cancer Society estimated 39,840 women died from breast cancer. that’s 796,800 abortions a year.

    • The most recent numbers I had (not estimates, but reported numbers) were from 2005 and 2006 – just over 40,000 deaths due to breast cancer, over 820,000 legal abortions reported.

  • Mia

    well i was just doing the math, my number times 20.

    it really shocks me that so little people care about such a HUGE epidemic that has been sweeping the nation since Roe v Wade. in Freakonomics i believe it talks about how there is an abortion for every 2.25 live births which equates to an abortion per 140 Americans. that stat makes me sick.

    also to stay on topic of this breast cancer topic, the “i <3 boobies" bracelets & that sort of thing are really extremely frustrating. i know a ton of kids at my school have them purely for the fact that they say "boobies". i think people need to realize what a sensitive subject breast cancer is and i think by playing it down with things like those bracelets is only making it seem like less of a big deal. that just seems counterproductive to the raising awareness if it's becoming more & more casual.

    i agree it's wrong that this trumps leading causes of death in the united states, but i don't think the attention is going to shift from breast cancer to something higher on the list of leading causes of death. therefore, i think we need to readjust our focus on breast cancer. i think we need to realize how emotionally & physically traumatizing it can be to families & the women who get it, and to stop playing it down with silly things like "i <3 boobies" bracelets or "save the ta-tas" bumper stickers. quite frankly, there are people—women, mothers, sisters, wives—attached to those body parts, and our focus should be them.

    it really shows where America's focus is when we start caring more about the body part & less about the human being that's attached to it.

  • Nathan Marone

    Aside from all of that, hot pink looks UGLY on football player’s uniforms.

  • As someone who works with breast cancer patients, I don’t see it from your perspective. I don’t see the sexualization of America as playing any significant role in the interest in breast cancer. I think the interest has to do with the fact that 1 in 8 women will be diagnosed in their lifetime so nearly everyone has a friend or a family member who has dealt with this disease. Cancer also moves people because it is scary – there may be some ways to reduce your risk, but it is not nearly as preventable as say heart disease which is the #1 killer. We know that diet, exercise, maintenance of an appropriate BMI, etc..will drastically reduce risk of heart disease and stroke but there is no such “simple” formula for breast cancer prevention. It affects women of all ages, races, socioeconomic status and is very likely to significantly affect one of your loved ones (and mine). I’m not arguing with the thought that abortion kills far too many – I agree. But that doesn’t take away the significance of the thousands of women who are lost to breast cancer each year and the hundreds of thousands of family members affected by that loss. BOTH issues are perfectly worthy of our attention. In my humble opinion.

    • I agree that we should care. We should probably care about everything that kills, though, not just breast cancer. It does make sense that this is a less-discriminating killer than heart disease that in some cases is preventable, so we have compassion on those sick and dying as long as they aren’t dying of a “fatty disease” that could have been prevented if the people just looked more attractive.

      I don’t think this explains it away, that the disease that is the cause of less than 2% of deaths, is the one we’re obsessed with.

      I suppose another way to say it that might bring clarity is that like you wrote, breast cancer can attack any type of woman, regardless of heath, weight, etc. Is it the valid logical conclusion to say that we as a culture are showing that we believe the life of a woman is more important than the life of a man, the life of a skinny person is worth more than a fat person, the life of the young worth more than the old, and by far, the life of an adult worth more than the life of a baby?

      (Again, I believe we should care and seek a cure – I’m not downplaying breast cancer or its effects AT ALL, just trying to figure out the disconnect between the promotion of breast cancer awareness and the reality that it kills less people than so many other killers.)

  • Lindsey

    Heart disease has very little with looking attractive and much more to do with what excess adipose tissue does to the vessels and organs. The American Heart Association is very active with many awareness campaigns, fundraisers, etc. In fact there is an awareness day/month/association for just about every disease under the sun. I don’t understand your conclusions about women being more valued than men, thin vs. fat, etc…. Breast cancer affects men as well as women, and thin people with high cholesterol and other risk factors are widely affected by heart disease. I guess you have to choose the cause closest to your heart whether it is related to a personal interest, loved ones affected or what you feel is philosophically the most pressing issue in society and get behind it. Your #1 concern may not be mine and mine may not be yours which is probably a good thing for society in general as there are plenty of causes to go around that need attention.

    • But in general, shouldn’t the cause closest to my heart – and that which I try to rally other people to – be in some way correlated with what kills the most people? That’s the conflict I’m trying to resolve.

  • Mia

    SO, i’m just really interested in this post mostly because my FB status about breast cancer last week got like 30 comments & most of them were by immature teenagers.

    Jon, most people have absolutely NO idea that abortion is the number one killer. most people don’t believe abortion is killing. there is, however, no doubt that breast cancer & other such diseases are killing people, but abortion is apparently debatable. It is wrong that everyone turns a blind eye to abortion, but seeing as it’s such a hot button topic it’s hard to convince people that it is truly the number one killer in America. for that to happen, everyone in America would need to agree that abortion is murder. clearly that is not going to happen.

    just because something is the number one killer doesn’t mean it’s close to everyone’s heart. not everyone is personally effected by abortion, therefore it’s not a big deal to everyone.

  • ben

    I think it’s because it affects primarily women. Ovarian cancer, despite killing even less, is now getting more coverage than other cancers that are much more fatal.